Level 7, 55 Collins Street, MelbourneMon to Fri, 8.30am to 6pm03 8375 4177
Buying · 7 min read

Asset sale vs share sale: the commercial differences

The commercial differences between buying a business's assets and buying the company that owns it: what transfers, liabilities, contracts, staff and how wide due diligence must go.

At a glance

  • In a share sale, you buy the company that owns the business. Everything inside the company comes with it, including its past.
  • In an asset sale, you buy chosen assets from the company, such as equipment, stock, the name and customer contracts. The company itself, and what you do not take, stays with the seller.
  • A share sale means wider due diligence and more reliance on warranties and indemnities. An asset sale means more contracts to transfer and staff to re-employ.
  • Tax and stamp duty can differ a great deal between the two, for buyer and seller. That is for your accountant or registered tax agent, and the documents are for your lawyer.

Two ways to buy the same business

If the business you want is run through a company, a Pty Ltd, there are two broad ways to buy it.

Share sale. You buy the shares in the company from its shareholders. The company keeps trading as before. It still owns its assets, employs its staff, holds its contracts and owes its debts. Only the owners change.

Asset sale. You, or a company you set up, buy the business assets from the company. You choose what to buy and agree what to leave behind. The seller's company still exists after the sale, with whatever you did not take.

The same business can be sold either way. Which one suits depends on the business, the risks in it, and the tax position of each side. Buyers and sellers can start with different preferences, and the choice is part of the negotiation.

Hypothetical example · a freight company, what the buyer takes under each routeA share sale takes everything. An asset sale takes what you choose.
Share sale: you buy the company The company, with its whole history Trucks and equipment Customer contracts Lease Staff Name and website Debts and claims Tax and past disputes Asset sale: you pick what you buy Your own entity Trucks and equipment Customer contracts* Lease* Name and website Staff, by new offer* Stays with the seller's company Debts and claims Tax and past disputes the past comes too

* May need the other party's consent, a new agreement or a new employment offer. Lime: what the buyer takes on purpose. Coral: what comes with the company whether you want it or not. The split in a real deal is set by the sale agreement.

The commercial differences

At a glance · share sale and asset sale compared, commercial points onlyNeither is simpler. The work just sits in different places.
Share saleAsset sale
What you buyThe company, with everything in itThe assets you list in the agreement
Past liabilitiesStay inside the company, so they become your problem as owner. You rely on due diligence, warranties and indemnitiesGenerally stay with the seller, unless you agree to take them on. Your lawyer should confirm what can still follow the assets
Customer and supplier contractsStay with the company. Check for clauses that let the other party end the contract if the company changes ownerNeed to be transferred, which often needs the other party's consent or a new agreement
LeaseStays with the company, but the lease may need the landlord's consent to a change in controlNeeds to be assigned to you, usually with the landlord's consent, or a new lease
StaffStay employed by the same company. Their entitlements stay with themNeed new offers from your entity. How past service and entitlements are treated is an employment law question
Licences, permits and registrationsHeld by the company, though some have change of control rulesMay not transfer. You may need to apply for your own
Due diligence scopeWide: the company's full history, including tax, disputes, compliance and past contractsNarrower: the assets, contracts and staff you are taking, and any liabilities that could follow them
Tax and stamp dutyCan differ a great deal between the two, for both sides. Get tax advice before you agree the structure

A worked example

Take a made-up freight company with 20 staff, a fleet of trucks and a depot lease. A buyer is weighing up a share sale against an asset sale. All facts here are made up to show the method.

Due diligence finds four things.

  • A $150k customer claim for damaged goods, still unresolved.
  • A depot lease at a rent below today's market, with eight years to run. It needs the landlord's consent to assign it or to change the company's owner.
  • Two large customer contracts that can be ended if the company changes hands.
  • Some trucks under finance, with the lender's security registered over them.
Hypothetical example · freight company, how each finding plays out under each routeA claim like this is easier to leave behind in an asset sale. The contracts need the customers on side either way. The contracts make both routes work.
FindingUnder a share saleUnder an asset sale
$150k customer claimStays in the company you now own. Needs a specific indemnity from the seller, perhaps backed by money held back from the priceStays with the seller's company, if the agreement says so
Below-market leaseKept by the company, subject to the landlord's consent to the change of ownerNeeds the landlord to consent to an assignment. The landlord may ask for new terms
Two big customer contractsCustomers can end them on the change of owner. Talk to them before completionNeed to be transferred, so the customers have to agree. Talk to them before completion
Trucks under financeThe finance stays with the company. Factor the debt into the priceThe finance usually needs to be paid out, or the lender must agree, before the trucks pass to you

Neither route makes every problem go away. The claim is easier to leave behind in an asset sale. The customer contracts need the customers on side either way. The real question is which route gives the buyer the business it wants with the fewest surprises, at a price and tax cost both sides can accept. That last part needs tax advice for both buyer and seller.

What to work out before heads of agreement

1

Ask which route the seller wants, and why

The answer can reveal the seller's tax position or a liability they would rather leave with you.

2

List the consents

Leases, key contracts, finance and licences. Who must agree, and can the deal close without them?

3

Scope due diligence to the route

A share sale needs a wider review of the company's history. Budget the time and cost for it.

4

Plan for staff

Under an asset sale, decide who gets an offer and on what terms. Get employment law advice on entitlements.

5

Get tax and legal advice early

The structure can change the after-tax result for both sides. Raise it before the price is agreed, because the structure can change the after-tax result for both sides.

The route is often discussed in heads of agreement, so it helps to raise it early. Our guides on heads of agreement, what commercial due diligence covers and the buying a business checklist cover the next steps.

Get the right people on each part. This guide covers commercial differences only. Whether liabilities, contracts or staff entitlements transfer in your deal is a legal question for your lawyer. GST, stamp duty, capital gains and other tax outcomes are for your accountant or registered tax agent. Every fact in the example is made up. This guide is general information only, not legal, tax or financial advice.

Know what you are taking on before you sign

An Acquisition Opportunity Assessment checks the seller's earnings, grades the top deal risks and sets out what due diligence should cover, and in what order, so you go into heads of agreement knowing what to raise with your lawyer. Fixed fee of $3,995 + GST. Facts in this guide are hypothetical.

See the Acquisition Opportunity Assessment

General information only, not advice for your circumstances. See our terms.

Tell us about the decision.

We reply within one business day with whether we can help, the service we would start with and its fixed fee.

Call 03 8375 4177Speak with an adviser