Oliver Advisory is part of Valuo · Sister firm of Oliver GroupContact
Fixed-fee commercial advice from $1,495 + GST · scope and fee agreed in writing before we start See all fees →
Independent business and commercial advisory · Level 7, 55 Collins Street, MelbourneMon to Fri, 8.30am to 6pm · 03 8375 4177
Selling · 7 min read

Quality of earnings, explained for owners

What a quality of earnings review is, the adjustments it makes to reported profit, and how owners can prepare before a buyer or investor runs one.

At a glance

  • A quality of earnings review asks one question: what profit does this business really make, year in, year out?
  • It starts with reported profit and adjusts for items that won't continue, such as one-off costs, personal expenses and non-market wages or rent.
  • Adjustments can go both ways. Some lift profit, some cut it.
  • Each adjustment is only as good as its evidence. Owners who prepare the evidence early are in a much stronger position.

What it is

A quality of earnings review (often called a QoE) takes the profit in your accounts and works out how much of it is the business's normal, ongoing earning power. The result is usually called normalised or adjusted earnings.

Buyers and investors often order these reviews before committing to a deal. Some owners order their own before going to market, so they know what a buyer's review will find.

Why reported profit needs adjusting

Private company accounts are usually prepared for tax and compliance, not for a buyer. That is perfectly normal. But it means the profit figure can include things a new owner won't inherit, and leave out costs a new owner will have to pay.

A few common examples:

  • One-off costs: a legal dispute, a relocation, a system change.
  • Personal or discretionary costs: a family member on the payroll who doesn't work in the business, or private expenses.
  • Owner's pay: if you pay yourself less than it would cost to hire someone to do your job, a buyer will adjust for the full cost.
  • Related-party arrangements: rent paid to your own property trust above or below the market rate.
  • Changes that have already happened: a major customer lost part-way through the year, whose profit won't continue.

The earnings bridge

The clearest way to see a quality of earnings review is as a bridge from reported profit to normalised earnings. Each step is one adjustment.

Hypothetical example: earnings bridge for a food manufacturing business with $20m revenue and reported EBITDA of $2.0m
Reported EBITDA $2.00m One-off legal costs +$0.12m Non-working family wage +$0.08m Owner salary below market -$0.10m Related-party rent below market -$0.06m Customer lost during the year -$0.20m Normalised EBITDA $1.84m

Grey steps add to profit. Bronze steps take it away. In this example the owner might have expected the review to add back costs and lift profit. Instead, the full cost of the owner's role, a market rent and the lost customer take off $0.36m. After the $0.20m of add-backs, normalised EBITDA is $0.16m lower, at $1.84m.

EBITDA here means earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation. Some reviews work from a different profit line. The method is the same.

Not every adjustment is equal

Buyers accept adjustments that are clearly evidenced and push back on those that aren't. The table rates each adjustment in the example by how well it is supported.

Hypothetical example: how well each adjustment in the bridge is supported
AdjustmentEvidence availableHow a buyer is likely to read it
One-off legal costs, +$0.12mInvoices, settlement deed, matter now closedStrong. Clearly non-recurring
Non-working family wage, +$0.08mPayslips; no role description or timesheetsModerate. Buyer will ask who does the work instead
Owner salary below market, -$0.10mOwner's current pay, compared with the cost of hiring a managerModerate. A buyer is likely to make this adjustment, but the amount depends on the cost of a hired manager
Rent below market, -$0.06mLease with owner's trust; no market rent adviceModerate. Amount may move once market rent is assessed
Lost customer, -$0.20mCustomer revenue and margin recordsStrong. Buyer will look for any other at-risk customers

Owners sometimes propose add-backs that a buyer won't accept, such as "we'll win that contract back" or "that cost was unusually high this year". Without evidence, these tend to fall away and can weaken trust in the rest of the numbers.

What a review usually looks at beyond the bridge

  • Trends: how revenue, margins and costs have moved over several years and months.
  • Working capital: how much cash the business ties up in customers and stock, and what a normal level looks like.
  • Cash conversion: whether profit turns into cash at a sensible rate.
  • Customer and product mix: where the profit actually comes from.

How to prepare

1

Get monthly accounts in order

Reconciled monthly management accounts for at least the last two to three years.

2

List every unusual item

One-off costs, personal expenses, family wages, related-party arrangements, and anything that changed during the year.

3

Gather the evidence

Invoices, payslips, leases, contracts. One folder per adjustment.

4

Be even-handed

Include the adjustments that reduce profit, not just the ones that lift it. Buyers will find them anyway.

5

Consider your own review

A review done before a sale lets you fix problems and tell the story on your terms.

What it is not

A quality of earnings review is not an audit, a tax review or a valuation. It doesn't tell you what the business is worth. A separate independent valuation may be needed if you want a formal opinion of value.

Check tax and legal points with your own advisers. Adjustments for personal expenses, family wages or related-party arrangements may raise questions about how those items were treated in past tax returns. Talk to your registered tax agent, and to your lawyer about related-party leases, before a buyer's review begins.

Know what your earnings will look like to a buyer

Our Commercial Due Diligence work includes a quality of earnings review that builds the bridge, tests the evidence, and shows where the questions will come from.

See the Commercial Due Diligence

General information only, not advice for your circumstances. See our terms.

Tell us about the decision.

We reply within one business day with whether we can help, the service we would start with and its fixed fee.

Call 03 8375 4177Speak with an adviser