Oliver Advisory is part of Valuo · Sister firm of Oliver GroupContact
Fixed-fee commercial advice from $1,495 + GST · scope and fee agreed in writing before we start See all fees →
Independent business and commercial advisory · Level 7, 55 Collins Street, MelbourneMon to Fri, 8.30am to 6pm · 03 8375 4177
Shareholders · 8 min read

When a shareholder wants out: the ways it usually ends

The common ways a shareholder leaves a private company, from the shareholders' agreement to a buy-out or sale, and the key questions each one raises.

At a glance

  • Start with the shareholders' agreement or constitution. If it sets out an exit process, that usually comes first.
  • The common paths are: the other shareholders buy, the company buys back the shares, an outside buyer, or selling the whole business.
  • Whatever the path, three questions decide it: what price, how it gets paid, and what the business looks like afterwards.
  • Get your lawyer and registered tax agent involved early. A separate independent valuation may be needed to settle the price.

Why these exits are hard

Private company shares have no ready market. You can't sell them on an exchange, and outside buyers can be reluctant to take a minority stake in a company they don't control. So most shareholder exits are settled among the people already involved, who often know each other well and may not agree on much by this stage.

The way through is usually less about winning an argument and more about finding a price and payment plan the business can actually afford.

Start with the paperwork

Before anything else, find the shareholders' agreement and the company constitution, if it has one. Many set out what happens when someone wants to leave: who must be offered the shares first, how the price is worked out, and over what period it is paid. If there is a process, it usually needs to be followed. If there is none, or it is unclear, the shareholders will need to agree a path. Your lawyer should read these documents with you.

The usual paths

Hypothetical example: decision path for an engineering services company with $12m revenue, where a 20% shareholder wants to leave
A shareholder wants out Does the agreement set an exit process? Yes Follow that process No or unclear Can they agree a path? Yes No Other holders buy Company buys back Outside buyer Sell whole business Mediation, or advice from your lawyer The example: no exit process in the agreement, shareholders agree the other two will buy

How the paths compare

Hypothetical example: the four agreed paths, as they apply to the same engineering services company
PathHow it worksWhat to watch
Other shareholders buyThe two remaining 40% holders buy the 20% stake between themWhether they can fund it personally or through borrowing, and how payments are secured
Company buys backThe company pays for the shares and cancels themFormal legal steps, the company's cash and solvency, and the tax treatment for everyone. Lawyer and tax agent essential
Outside buyerA new investor buys the 20% stakeOften limited by first-offer rights in the agreement, and an outside buyer may not want a minority stake
Sell the whole businessAll shareholders sell togetherOnly works if everyone wants to sell. A much bigger decision than one person leaving

The three questions that decide it

1. What price?

This is usually the hardest part. The agreement may say how the price is set. If not, the parties need to agree an approach. A separate independent valuation may be needed. Raise how the price should be set with your lawyer early.

2. How does it get paid?

This is where many exits succeed or stall. The leaving shareholder wants certainty. The remaining shareholders want terms the business can survive. A payment plan often bridges the two.

Hypothetical example: a $1.0m agreed price for the 20% stake, paid over two years
Payments to the leaving shareholder ($k) $400k At completion bank loan $300k End of year 1 from cash flow $300k End of year 2 from cash flow

Before agreeing to a plan like this, the remaining shareholders need to know the business can generate that cash on top of its normal needs, after tax, without starving itself of working capital or equipment. The leaving shareholder will want to know what happens if a payment is missed. Your lawyer can advise on security and terms.

3. What does the business look like afterwards?

If the leaving shareholder also works in the business, who takes over their role? Do key customers or staff deal mainly with them? Is there a restraint on them competing? An exit that strips out a key person and the cash at the same time can hurt the business the others are paying to keep.

Where commercial advice fits

Commercial advice helps everyone see the same picture: what each path means for the business, how much cash it can realistically commit, and what risks follow the exit. That makes the conversation about facts rather than positions.

We don't act as a broker, introduce buyers, or negotiate on anyone's behalf for a success fee. We also don't advise anyone on whether to buy or sell shares. Those decisions belong to the shareholders, with their own lawyers and tax advisers.

Get legal and tax advice early. Shareholder exits involve the company's constitution, any shareholders' agreement, company law steps and tax for both the company and the individuals. Each shareholder should consider getting their own lawyer and registered tax agent. If the relationship has broken down, ask your lawyer about mediation before positions harden.

Work out an exit the business can afford

Shareholder Exit Advisory sets out the paths available, tests what the business can fund, and helps shareholders see the same commercial picture, with each taking their own legal and tax advice.

See the Shareholder Exit Advisory

General information only, not advice for your circumstances. See our terms.

Tell us about the decision.

We reply within one business day with whether we can help, the service we would start with and its fixed fee.

Call 03 8375 4177Speak with an adviser